Showing posts with label Brandon Sullivan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Brandon Sullivan. Show all posts
Brandon Sullivan 🎤 Ulster Said No, Loyalists Went on the Rampage: They’ve Lost every Fight They’ve Started Since

How this situation came about can be summed up as follows. In November 1985, the government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain & Northern Ireland signed an agreement with Ireland. For the first time, Dublin had a say in the governing of NI - albeit an advisory role, Unionists were apoplectic with fury, and the “Ulster Says No" campaign was a launched. Whilst unionist paranoia had reached a fever pitch, there did seem to be a new determination on the security forces to face down loyalist street disorder. Or, to be more accurate, there seemed to be the political will to use the RUC to quell loyalist street disorder. Much, but by no means all of this, seemed to be in Portadown, more specifically, Obins Street.

For many years, Orange Order parades travelled through Obins Street on their way to Drumcree Parish Church. Nationalist residents increasingly objected to the marches, arguing that repeated loyalist parades through their area were intimidating and that they were not treated equally when seeking to hold St Patrick’s Day parades elsewhere in Portadown.

In 1985, tensions escalated following disputes surrounding parades in Portadown. In response to growing disorder, the Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC) decided to prevent Orange Order marches from using the Obins Street/Tunnel route. In 1986, after further serious violence, the route was formally redirected. The Orange Order subsequently travelled towards Drumcree using the Garvaghy Road, which created a new and even more prominent dispute as more houses were built, which were occupied by Catholics.

At Obins Street, Unionist politicians could be heard saying to loyalist protestors that “Dublin’s giving the orders.” Ian Paisley himself, at a political event in June 1986, added to the increasing hysteria in his own tried and tested formulaic way: the BBC reporting that:

after accusing some of the police officers of mistreating him, Reverend Paisley shouted: "Don't come crying to me if your homes are attacked. You will reap what you sow".

Drumcree in the 1990s – Standing Up for God and Ulster

In the early hours of one summer morning, in the mid-1990s, a senior RUC officer walked to where a mother was standing with her young sons, who would have been about the same ages as the murdered Quinn brothers. The boys were wavering, tired, their eyes starting to close. The RUC man addressed the mother: “would you not be better off getting those wee boys home to bed?” The mother looked down and barked at her children “stand up straight for God and Ulster!” The incident stayed in the RUC man’s mind for many years after it happened.

The Orange Order, and violent loyalism was defeated at Drumcree. The “Orange Card” – which was basically “might is right” in the form of the threat of apocalyptic violence, never carried the same weight again. Loyalists tried it a few more times, with diminishing returns.

Obins, Drumcree, Harryville, Holy Cross, Flags… Loyalists lost every fight they’ve started.
Until 2026… and The Ruling by the Parades Commission

In decades to come, this will still be seen as the stupidest, most counterproductive decision taken by an entity in Northern Ireland. Conspiracy theories will abound as to why on earth close to 30 years of peace was upended by a decision.

But, the fact remains, that the Parades Commission made that decision. It ruled that 35 Orangemen could march silently, at 8am, down the Garvaghy Road.

The residents, and their supporters, blocked the road. In doing so, they adopted an approach which has some similarities to that which loyalists of the 90s took – they went for might-is-right. Let me head off any criticism of the comparison: there is a massive difference. Those on the Garvaghy Road are peaceful, are not threatening widespread murder and disorder, and are behaving in an unreproachable manner.

But they were happy with the Parades Commission until it made a decision they didn’t like, at which point they used sheer physical presence to prevent its decision being carried out.

Isn’t that hypocrisy?

Isn’t that what Bryson and Portadown LOL No 1 want?

Wouldn’t it have been better to let the 35 prize specimens waddle silently down a road and then take to the courts to make sure it doesn’t happen again?

My Tuppence Worth

I think the Chief Constable of the PSNI has a raft of issues, personal and political, that make him ill-suited to dealing with the situation that has unfolded. Within his ranks are Continuity RUC types, that probably dislike him as much as they dislike the residents of the Garvaghy Road. Could these officers have offered the Parades Commission some sort of false guarantees? Could this be about getting Boutcher to resign? Predictably, some are calling for it. Yet he won’t go. But he’s going to be having a bad week or two.

Jamie Bryson, on the other hand, will be delighted. He’d have been devastated if the Orangemen had got to go for a silent Sunday stroll.

Should nationalists have shown some magnanimous pathos and let the Orangemen take their heavily restricted walk?

This piece is designed to stimulate debate. I hope that it follows.

⏩Brandon Sullivan is a middle-aged West Belfast émigré. He juggles fatherhood & marriage with working in a policy environment and writing for TPQ about the conflict, films, books, and politics.

Should The Garvaghy Road Residents Have Allowed The Orange Order To March Down Their Road?

Brandon Sullivan 🔖 As everyone who’s read Helter Skelter by Vincent Bugliosi knows, Charles Manson was a hippy cult leader who wanted to start a race war by murdering a number rich white people and blaming it on the Black Panthers.


His theory for this race war, known as Helter Skelter, was informed in part by The Beatles White Album, released in 1968. Again, this is known, accepted fact, detailed in the 7 million selling book, Helter Skelter. The author, Vincent Butliosi, was in a position to know this, as he was the prosecutor in the case against Manson, and a number of his followers. I myself read Helter Skelter some years ago and thoroughly enjoyed it.

The problem is, sadly, that Bugliosi, to put it mildly, lied, lied, and lied again. The Helter Skelter idea, and it did exist, was just that: an idea. One of many discussed by Manson as he preached to his followers at ranches in the Los Angeles desert. As Tom O’Neill, the author of this magnificent and majestic book, said in an Error Morris (of Fog of War and Thin Blue Line fame) documentary: “we don’t know what happened. But we definitely know that what we were told happen isn’t what happened.”

O’Neill’s journalism is epic in its scale. The cast of characters in this book is astounding. I was familiar with the FBI’s COINTELPRO operation, and how it targeted the civil rights movement. But the CIA’s domestic operations, Chaos, and MKUltra, I hadn’t heard about. In forensic detail, O’Neill illustrates how the FBI committed extrajudicial killings of Black Panthers, which I was aware of previously but not in such depth, but also how the CIA conducted experiments on “unwitting, let alone consenting” American citizens, which led to at least two deaths. CIA scientists wanted to create individuals who would kill on command without remorse, and experimented with hypnosis and LSD to create such “Manchurian candidates” – of course, infamously, Charles Manson did just that. The coincidences don’t stop there. The major CIA scientist involved in these experiments, Dr “Jolly” West, had an office in the Haight-Ashbury Free Medical Center. Which is also where Charles Manson’s parole officer had an office and would meet him. And it’s also where Manson would bring his female followers for treatment for STIs and unwanted pregnancies. O’Neill is open about not being able to prove a link between the CIA’s operations and Manson, but the coincidences are absolutely incredible. Or incredulous. The reader is left to decide.

So, why did Manson charge his followers with murdering the occupants of 10050 Cielo Drive, and a middle class couple the next day? Well, a number of theories are explored. Vincent Bugliosi, in his prosecution and in his best-selling book, stated that the Cielo house was targeted to murder the record producer Terry Melcher (son of Doris Day) who, who had angered Manson by rejecting him for a recording contract. Except, as O’Neill diligently pointed out, Manson knew he had moved out of that property (because Melcher was scared of his housekeeper, he claimed) and Melcher also met Manson several times after the murders were committed. As O’Neill pointed out, his discoveries revealed that Melcher perjured himself, as did Bugliosi. This anomalies are among literally hundreds that O’Neill uncovers. The story of his O’Neill first got into this subject, and stayed the course over 20 years is a story worthy of a book itself.

I can’t recommend this book highly enough. If anyone is interested in true crime, the Manson murders, the counter culture, the FBI/CIA, Hollywood in the late 1960s, or just plain ol’ forensic journalism, then this book is essential reading.

I hope someone else on the blog reads it and does a better review than me.

Check out the documentary on Netflix, or the interview on Joe Rogan. I actually listened to the audiobook, then bought a hard copy to access the notes at the end, which are meticulously kept.

★10/10.★

Tom O'Neill with Dan Piepenbring, 2019. Chaos: Charles Manson, the CIA and the Secret History of the Sixties.William Heinemann Ltd. ISBN-13: 978-1785152078

⏩Brandon Sullivan is a middle-aged West Belfast émigré. He juggles fatherhood & marriage with working in a policy environment and writing for TPQ about the conflict, films, books, and politics.

Chaos 📚 Charles Manson, The CIA, And The Secret History Of The Sixties

Brandon Sullivan 🎵 One weekday afternoon, I was skiving school and went with some friends to smoke hash. 

My memory tells me that it was a bright, sunny day, but memory is a fallible thing. One thing for sure, though, is that I was dedicated to rave music and considered myself, in my teenage delusion, a connoisseur with rarified tastes, full of disdain for “commercial” rave music, and preferring Derrick May and Dave Angel. Anyway, on this particular day, my life changed, because Champagne Supernova was playing on a Hi-Fi (remember them?) and I was transfixed. “What’s that?” Oasis. “It’s incredible.” That was 30 years ago. I listened to What’s The Story (Morning Glory) relentlessly, and then Definitely Maybe. Be Here Now was still some time away.

Getting into Oasis opened up a world of other music. I’d read Q magazine every month, and back issues in the school library (many of which were “liberated” and ended up in a huge collection I donated to Oxfam some time ago) and would be entranced at who Noel had ripped his songs off of. I remember during a house party a Best of 70s CD was playing and Oasis’ Cigarettes & Alcohol started and we all looked at each other stunned. Except it wasn’t: it was Get it On by T-Rex. Interestingly, a rave version of a T-Rex song “Children of the Revolution” was already well known to my friend group. A throwback to this article.

I saw Oasis at Loch Lomond in 1996. Four of us went, three of whom worked at McDonald’s. We asked for the day off, and the next day, and were refused. We basically laughed and said we were going anyway, and did. It was an amazing day. I had a sense that we were experiencing something significant, and it was. Weirdly, I clearly remember Dreadzone playing. The Manic Street Preachers got boo’d, something I’d have been happy with then, ashamed at now. Oasis came on, the helicopter noise from What’s the Story booming over the PA, and Liam in a duffle coat came out, kissed Noel, swaggered over to the mic and shouted “Columbia” – my favourite Oasis song – possibly, from a crowded field, the highlight of my teenage years. I saw then again in 2000, at Murrayfield, but don’t remember much. It was in the middle of a binge lasting a few days. I do remember the walk there, it seemed like everybody I’d ever known was on their way there, and the craic was mighty. I don’t think any photos exist of any of us at either of the shows. It’s just the way it was then. Maybe it’s a shame, maybe it’s for the best.

So, when Oasis reformed, I was interested. I tried to get tickets on the day they were released, and failed, like a lot of people. At one stage I considered buying a ticket for the New Jersey show, but with young kids to look after, that would be tricky. Then, as the day approached, I knew I couldn’t miss it. I bought a ticket for almost £300, and made my way there. Unlike 2000, I didn’t see anyone I knew, though I knew a lot of friends were there, in the standing area, partying away. I had a good seat, with a clear view. I missed Cast, caught and enjoyed Richard Ashcroft, and then Oasis came on . . . 

They sounded great, and Liam was full of mischief, berating the City of Edinburgh council for comments about Oasis fans (not, it must be said, all that inaccurate). The atmosphere was more like a family friendly rave than a concert. People were smiling, talking, chatting. The Poznan was requested from Liam, and everyone complied. They didn’t play Columbia, and Hello, with its Gary Glitter origin felt a little bit suspect, but the set was filled with the hits and gave people exactly what they wanted, and a little bit more. Noel went a bit boomer dad with an intro to Don’t Look Back in Anger asking if there were any “atheist lesbians” in the audience.

I don’t think this tour will be a one-off. It has been such an incredible success, that I don’t think either warring Gallagher brother will want it to be over after this. But who knows – I didn’t think they’d be split for 16 years. As Noel once said “it’s always hard working with family. But when your family is Liam Gallagher, it’s even harder.”

⏩Brandon Sullivan is a middle-aged West Belfast émigré. He juggles fatherhood & marriage with working in a policy environment and writing for TPQ about the conflict, films, books, and politics.

Oasis 🎸 Live ‘25

Brandon Sullivan 🎤 Quillversation with Jonathan Trigg, author of the newly released book: Death in Derry: Martin McGuinness and the Derry IRA’s War Against the British, and his first book in this area, the well-received Death in the Fields: The IRA in East Tyrone.

It’s my pleasure to start another Quillversation with Jon Trigg. This time, the focus is on Derry, where the late Martin McGuinness held sway for a very long time. As with the last Quillversation with Jon, my hope is that questions will follow, and we’ll get another piece. Or two, as proved to be the case last time.

Please add your own questions in the comments below, or comments on the answer, or indeed questions, on this piece.

Let’s get started.

Brandon Sullivan (BS): You wrote the well-received book on the East Tyrone Brigade (ETB). In writing the Derry book, did you do anything differently?

Did writing the ETB book make the Derry book easier or harder to write?

Jon Trigg (JT): Very kind of you to say on the ETB book, I'd probably say it was well received by some, less so by some others. In retrospect I probably wasn't prepared as I thought I was for some of the criticism, which was pretty vitriolic. Naive of me really, this is a very emotive subject with people holding very strong views indeed, so one thing I did differently was 'armour' myself better for what I now knew would come my way.

The second, and far more important thing I wanted to do in the Derry book was to interview more former volunteers than I'd been able to for Tyrone. They're the lifeblood of the books and that's where Death in the Fields came in very handy. I don't flatter myself that every former volunteer devoured every word of it, but the feedback I got from the Derry guys was that they'd read - or heard - enough of it to think they would get a fair hearing. They also believed - rightly - their words wouldn't be distorted or their identities revealed, and on that basis I had a lot more people willing to be interviewed, and that made a huge difference. Experience always helps too, so having written one book on a PIRA brigade, I was hopefully better equipped to write another - but I'll let the readers judge that.

BS: In terms of the reviews that you received, one thing that I saw as positive and interesting was that it started conversations on TPQ, and I presume among former volunteers, and amongst people like myself, amateur historians/researchers.

Did any of your sources for the Derry book give a specific reason or rationale for their participation?

Going back to the reviews again, what stands out as being useful?

And going to the content of the book itself, let's start off with a fairly standard question - simply, what were the main differences between the ETB and the Derry Brigade?

JT: Yes I think it did, and I see that as a big win - if we want something to die then a good way of achieving that is not to talk about it, and I strongly believe that would be a major error for the Troubles and do all those from all sides who fought and suffered a huge disservice.

By far the most common reason sources gave me for participating was to ensure their side of what happened was recorded and heard by the wider public. For Seán McGlinchey - who was very kind in giving up his time to meet - he knows he's a well-known figure with a public profile and his past is documented, but often without any input from him and he wanted the opportunity to talk about it in his own words. For other former volunteers quite a few had never been asked to talk before and felt their stories had been overlooked and would soon be forgotten. They'd devoted their lives to the Movement and while they didn't want plaudits or brass bands they wanted that commitment remembered in some way.

Strangely enough there were echoes of the same motivations among some of the ex-members of the security forces I interviewed. None of them were 'bigwigs' or the men in the headlines but they wanted their experiences recorded and remembered.

As for reviews I was initially going to say 'all reviews are useful', but then I remembered those that aren't; I've had several that simply said 'after ordering, the book arrived quickly' . . . useful for Amazon perhaps but less so for me. Reviews can be helpful though, less so perhaps for specific points but more in terms of a 'general view', so if readers consistently point out a lack of balance on an aspect of the book, for example, that's useful. One such theme I get quite a lot of is where readers say the book leans too heavily towards one side but is a good read nonetheless - I get that from both sides of the fence, so am I doing something right? Perhaps.

For the South Derry units and the ETB they had a lot in common and fought broadly similar wars, but Derry city PIRA was very different as you'd expect. Firstly, the geography of the war in Derry was hugely compressed compared to the ETB. Operations were often sandwiched into small networks of streets, lanes and alleys, and that flowed through to the type of operations carried out. The Derry Brigade couldn't launch the type of attacks the ETB often could - large road mines, improvised mortars and major assaults on police stations, because of the danger to civilians. Of course that was mostly to avoid innocent bloodshed, but let's be clear it also had a practical, military driver as well in attacks like that eroded support from the communities they operated in, and that was very dangerous.

I'd also say a big difference between the two was the men in the ranks themselves. In general terms the ETB relied on recruits from a network of families with republican traditions that had links with each other often going back generations. That links with motivation too - the ETB's war sprung in large part from the land itself and what they viewed as the injustice of confiscations that happened centuries previously. This wasn't the case in Derry. Civil rights and not land were bigger motivators there as you'd expect in the city that suffered the tragedy of Bloody Sunday. In Derry the links that bound ETB members weren't as strong - or so tied up in history, and the very proximity to each other of volunteers in the city made security so much harder, hence why Derry was easier for the security forces to penetrate and the likes of Raymond Gilmour for instance could do so much damage.

The biggest difference though - in my opinion - was Martin McGuinness. The ETB had some notable commanders in its time; Kevin Mallon, Patrick Kelly etc, but no-one like McGuinness. His longevity and influence dominated the Brigade almost from its creation. You can see it in the brigade's lifecycle; when he was engrossed in the military struggle so was the brigade, when he began to move towards a political solution the brigade's military side withered.

BS: I’ve decided to cluster a series of questions and answers by topic:



Quillversation about Martin McGuiness (McG)

BS: I think one of the strengths if the book was the presence of McG - it wasn't a book about McG, or even about McG's command of Derry. I think it successfully showed Derry as an entity independent of McG. A few questions on McG:

Do you have an opinion on whether he was an agent of some type? Perhaps a strange question, but were you left with the impression that you'd have liked to have gone for a pint with McG?

What are your thoughts on him as a military leader? And as a leader of men more generally?

JT: I'd have very much liked to have had a quiet drink with McG, albeit I don't think he would have had a pint, a soft drink for him I think and he wouldn't have said much, far too cagey and self-possessed for a simple scribbler like me.

No, I don't think he was an agent of any type, despite the thoughts of some of my interviewees. Do I think there was more to his thinking - and perhaps his actions - than was apparent at the time? Perhaps, but not to the point where he was in any way working for the British. I do think, however -  and let me be very clear here that I have no written or verbal evidence for this whatsoever, this is purely my own 'hunch' if you like - that he had confidential back channels to the British (Security Service personnel in particular and that's not news of course) that he might have used on very rare occasions to discuss sensitive subjects of mutual benefit. But who knows for sure? Maybe we'll find out in years to come, but probably not.

Hmm, a military leader/leader of men, he was definitely a leader of men, he obviously inspired devotion and admiration among his own men and commanded both their respect and that of his enemies. He was a good tactician in many ways but what I would call his 'military knowledge' was not as good as it was made out to be. John Crawley makes some very good points about this in his book 'The Yank' - which is excellent by the way - and I agree with him. To be an effective military leader you need to have the basic knowledge of individual and small unit tactics, understand weapons systems and their characteristics as well as pros and cons, and have a good understanding of all the necessary facets of military leadership; training, logistics, communications, intelligence etc, and McG didn't have that. Perhaps more importantly he didn't either surround himself with (or delegate to) those that did have that knowledge, or seek to remedy the gaps in his knowledge through learning.

BS: I share your hunch - but at a certain point his interests became in-line with strategic British (though not RUC) interests. From memory there was a significant RUC operation against him (Operation Taurus). Had there been the political will, I think he could possibly have been convicted of "directing terrorism" a la Adair, and a UVF character named Maguire.

Crawley's criticisms of McGuinness's military leadership are hard to refute - it seems he had a natural charisma and an innate military cunning, but didn't seek to nurture these talents with appropriate training, or as you say surround himself with those who could fill the gaps or train him. Could this be a personality defect that he had? An arrogance? Or, as you say, do you think he simply got more interested in politics and the military aspect took a back seat?

I was trying to think of a comparison with McGuinness. Gerry Adams didn't really control Belfast, but he was obviously a strong influence. Slab Murphy is more analogous to McGuinness in terms of longevity and unquestioned leadership. But obviously Slab wasn't a politician, and in fact seems to have very little respect for most of them. Did you hear any commentary on McGuinness's relationships with, or attitudes to, figures such as Slab, or the former Chief of Staff Kevin McKenna (alleged to have had a non-violent feud with him).

JT: Very good questions on the 'why' with him. He was clearly hugely charismatic and an inspiring figure in republicanism, but why this lack of military leadership at anything above a very local, tactical level? He obviously was involved in operations and took risks personally - that is a very clear sign of a leader and one that would have gone a long way in inspiring devotion from his men, but why not kick on from there? True, I think his adoption of the car bomb and conviction that an economic offensive would be a pragmatic military pathway in Derry was something that in classic military thinking would be termed an 'operational' level, but he didn't appear to kick on from there - was the lure of politics too great, did Adams persuade him that was the route to success?

You're right on Slab Murphy, but I would say Murphy was a better military leader than McG as he evolved and in particular - and I would be the first to admit I'm no expert on S Armagh - he did indeed delegate to others around him and promote younger men around him who showed sharp tactical minds, ingenuity and innovation in their operations - S Armagh were also happy to learn the use of newer, heavier weapons which require military expertise to use effectively.

No commentary from Derry volunteers on McKenna and the alleged feud.

BS: John Crawley was a former training instructor with US Marine Reconnaissance teams. I imagine that South Armagh would have recognised Crawley would have been better employed training IRA volunteers in weapons and tactics than going into gun stores in New York to buy one rifle at a time because he had an American accent. In simple terms, McGuinness sent John Crawley to America to buy weapons. That is unimaginative at best, and purposefully damaging at worst.

In Derry, there wasn't an equivalent to "The Surgeon" that I could see, at least not in Derry City. South Derry was different, but they seem to have more in common with the ETB than South Armagh.

Were many volunteers positive about McGuinness?

JT: That's exactly what I’d have used John Crawley to do, and I would have ensured his 'shopping list' of weapons was what he got. Agreed on the commonality between South Derry and ETB, linkage across to West Tyrone and Donegal and tie in Fermanagh and you've got a 'super brigade' area.

There was no outright hostility to McG from any of the volunteers. Some had questions/concerns and one obviously believed he was compromised in some way, but almost all of them greatly admired him - they loved the fact that he was 'one of their own' and had risen so high in the Movement too.



Quillversation about sectarianism in the Derry IRA

BS: Were the 1974 murders of Winston Smith and Bert Slater ever discussed? How were Protestants, unionists, and loyalists generally discussed? And regarding the killing of Alan "Smudger" Smyth - was this well received by the volunteers you spoke to? The IRA in Derry had some successes against loyalist figures, reasonably high-profile UDA men were killed, and Smudger was quite a coup. And South Derry got a few UVF members.

Compared with the East Tyrone Brigade - how much did conflict with loyalists inform the attitudes/fears/motivations of republicans?

JT: In general the former Derry volunteers didn't say much about Protestants, unionists and loyalists. They very much thought the RUC and the UDR in particular were sectarian, albeit the city volunteers didn't have that much firsthand experience of the UDR. With the ETB it was a huge issue, I mean huge, and there were echoes of it among the S Derry volunteers - Sean McGlinchey was very clear about that - but it wasn't nearly as big a deal in the city.


Quillversation about informers in Derry

BS: The Derry brigade seemed to be badly affected by touts. What was the attitude to volunteers about them? I've read so many conflicting stories about Paddy "Warhead" Flood. Your Branch contact seemed emphatic. What did the volunteers think?

Did anyone ever discuss the paedophile John Collett who the IRA shot dead? Apparently he was a prolific child abuser, and the community put intense pressure on the IRA to do something, so they killed him.

JT: All the volunteers felt the same about informers - they detested them. They understandably saw them as the 'enemy within' and the greatest potential weakness in the Brigade. The city volunteers knew there was getting away from the fact that the city is fairly small so by necessity it was almost impossible not to know who was involved which made them very vulnerable.

Yes on Flood I've heard a lot of conflicting stories too, and the volunteers I spoke to weren't sure whether he was or not - they mostly didn't want to talk about it really. But the SB guy was clear on it, but I would have preferred to have more corroboration.

No-one mentioned Collett and I didn't ask any of the interviewees as I didn't think it important enough to be a line of questioning. I knew he was a habitual criminal but I didn't know he was a child abuser. CAIN has it down as a punishment shooting gone wrong which is what I went with in the book.


Quillversation about Patsy Gillespie

BS: Could you talk a bit more about this operation, how the volunteers felt about, and if anyone actually defended it?

JT: None of the volunteers defended it, although most were ambivalent about it, seeing it as a successful operation in that it killed soldiers but also understanding the strong emotions using Gillespie as a proxy bomb had inevitably evoked. As I say in the book the Gillespie operation was one of three coordinated to happen pretty much simultaneously - which is a sophisticated feat in itself requiring a lot of planning, logistics and communications. I can't help but think the proxy bomb concept is clumsy and not a sound military operation. In effect by bringing in an unwilling 'bomber' into the very heart of the action you lose the ability to control the attack.


Quillversation about Sinn Fein

BS: What was the volunteers attitudes to Sinn Fein? Any difference between the city and country volunteers in terms of attitudes?

JT: None of the volunteers were anti-Sinn Fein, mostly their attitude seemed to be that the party is a 'necessary evil' if the Movement is to achieve its goals; although interestingly none of them were personally involved in Sinn Fein. A few of them admired Michelle O'Neill, they hadn't met her but felt she'd outsmarted many other SF bigwigs by playing up the 'dumb blonde' persona while actually being a very savvy political operator.

Sean McGlinchey was pro-Sinn Fein as you'd expect from the former Mayor of Limavady, and I got the feeling from him the country volunteers were more pro-Sinn Fein on the whole than the city lads, seeing it a community organisation that very much worked in the interests of local nationalists across the board - the city volunteers were a little more sceptical about ts motives, but not overly much.


Quillversation about the security forces

BS: One of the strengths of the books was the inclusion and voice given to the army and RUC. What do the security forces have in common with volunteers? And what, besides the uniform (or lack of) are the main differences?

JT: I agree. This to me is one of the key drivers for the book - for all of them actually - the books aren't the story of the IRA told exclusively from the standpoint of the IRA - I want to give everyone a voice, including the army and the RUC - and even loyalists, because everyone was involved and has a story to tell. I want to prominently feature former volunteers because I feel strongly that the voices of the frontline volunteers has been largely unheard for a variety of reasons, some of them understandable, others less so. But that means walking a difficult and tricky path; and so much hinges on the use of language. When is a death a 'murder', or an 'execution'? Wherever I can I try not to describe an act myself but allow the interviewees to use their own language, but clearly that isn't possible for every incident in a book so that invariably means me as the author getting involved as it were, and I know from personal experience that can be very, very difficult for a lot of people. They contact me and tell me in no uncertain terms how angry my writing had made them - and that's from all sides, former security forces, volunteers etc.

On areas of common ground what a lot of interviewees (but by no means all!) have always told me about the other side as it were is that they respected the fact they believed in their cause - all sides thought the other sides' cause was wrong, but in general they knew it took commitment to adhere to it.

In terms of differences the three that stand out are resources, focus and training. For obvious reasons the security forces have vastly more resources than the volunteers, be that money, weapons, logistics, technology, you name it. But the second issue of 'focus' counterbalances that to a degree - not a huge degree, but some - and by that I mean for the British Army the war in Northern Ireland wasn't the be all and end all of soldiering, the main theatre was at the time in Western Germany and countering the Warsaw Pact. That's what the mass of equipment, training, preparation etc was geared for. Obviously that wasn't the case for the volunteers, for them the war in Northern Ireland was the Only war.

Lastly, there's training. For members of the security forces - and the army in particular - life revolves around training at all levels. Volunteers didn't have that luxury but at the same time I didn't get a sense from the volunteers that the organisation they were members of really valued or invested in training. As one interviewee said 'if you hadn't got the hang of a rifle or whatever in a couple of sessions then you never would.' I understand the thinking but don't agree. Training, training and more training is the key to successful soldiering, especially down at small unit size, for example an ASU.


The next book

BS: I think to finish up, maybe talk a little about future plans, approach to Belfast book and so on?

JT: The next subject is the Belfast Brigade. It will be a huge undertaking. It's where the Provisionals were really birthed and where so much of the heart of the Movement sat - and still does. Covering it in one book alone wouldn't do it justice in my view, so I'm looking at maybe two. I've asked a couple of former volunteers themselves their thoughts and they've suggested the time split might be '69-'77 for vol 1 and then vol 2 for the rest, but I'm not sure as yet. If TPQers have thoughts on that then please let me know.

As ever the key will be getting people to talk to me and so again, if anyone out there wants to talk to me then please get in touch via my website - there's a Contact me function they can use. As usual it would be confidential and if people want to be quoted anonymously then that's fine.

The debates I have with former volunteers who I'm close to has been around my use of language - and the Derry book is a case in point. Some have very strong feelings that my personal background comes through in the language I use and it demonises them. It's a huge dilemma for me personally and has made me reflect on the way I write. I'm not interested in my work on being a mouthpiece for any side, and I neither condemn nor applaud any side, but achieving objectivity in such a highly charged environment is difficult beyond belief and I accept I don't always attain the goal I set myself - and for that I ask forbearance. I will leave it to those like TPQers who are immersed in the subject to tell me where I'm going wrong, and hopefully where I'm going right too.

⏩ About Jonathan Trigg: Historian, writer and broadcaster, Jonathan Trigg has written over a dozen books with Death On The Don nominated in 2014 for the Pushkin Prize for Russian History. Latterly his Through German Eyes series exploring various Second World War campaigns and battles from the German perspective have been a critical and popular success. Inspired by events closer to home Jonathan has now embarked on a project to cover the Troubles. His first book on the subject - Death in the Fields: The IRA and East Tyrone was published by Merrion in Easter 2023.

Jonathan previously served in the 1st Battalion the Royal Anglian Regiment, reaching the rank of Captain, and completing emergency tours of East Tyrone and Bosnia. He left the Army after a final posting as a Military Instructor to the United Arab Emirates.

For further information and to contact Jonathan directly please visit his website

⏩Brandon Sullivan is a middle-aged West Belfast émigré. He juggles fatherhood & marriage with working in a policy environment and writing for TPQ about the conflict, films, books, and politics.

Quillversation With Jonathan Trigg 🪶 The Derry IRA

Brandon Sullivan ✍ The murders of Karen McKeown and William Nixon in 1982 have stuck in my mind ever since I learned about them.

The two victims, completely different from each other except it seems, their membership of the Protestant/Unionist/Loyalist community. In Ms McKeown’s case, her faith was an important part of her life and she worked at a church, teaching children about the bible. I could not find many details about the life of William Nixon, but I do know he was retired, and had no links to the security forces or loyalist paramilitaries. They were murdered in random, sectarian attacks, as were Edward McMaster, Marius O'Neill and Paul McCrory, Michael Fay, and many others of that era, I did not come much closer in finding out who murdered Ms McKeown and Mr Nixon, but I found a chronology of related incidents which I found intriguing. As ever, my hope is that respectful debate will follow.

The Murderer And The Mechanic

1982 was a violent year in Northern Ireland. Whilst the last few years of the 1970s had seen a marked decrease in political murder and violence, the early 1980s were times of extreme political tension and conflict. Republican hunger strikes in 1980 and 1981 had convulsed society, casting a shadow into the next year. The summer of 1982 saw the release of Lennie Murphy, and an attendant increase in murder. The killings continued, some of them linked to Murphy from beyond the grave.

A funeral took place in Belfast in late November 1982 for Michael Fay. The Protestant Action Force had said he was one of three Catholic men who were to die to "avenge Lennie Murphy." The murdered man, a 25-year-old, was buried following a service at St. Colmcille's church. The church was and is a beautiful ornate stone building with an imposing roof and long windows, no doubt built to accommodate the spiritual needs of Catholics from all over Ireland who went to Belfast in search of work at various points, when all of Ireland was under British rule. The church and its parish are in East Belfast, an area synonymous with the pillars of unionism and loyalism. Catholics were in a minority in Belfast in the 1980s, and in fact until a few years ago. In East Belfast, Catholics were a much smaller minority, living amongst, as one Belfast wit put it, "acres of Prods." Fay's workplace was on Gilnahirk Road, close to particularly tough loyalist estates such as the Braniel. It's possible that Michael felt a degree of safety in such a potentially dangerous situation because of his friendly relationships with members of the unionist community. One man with whom Michael socialised was his workmate, Billy Giles. Like Michael, Billy was a mechanic. In the early 1980s, home entertainment had been revolutionised with the advent of video cassettes, and Michael and Billy would have a cup of tea together at Billy's house in Kilmorey Gardens, in the Tullycarnet area of East Belfast, and watch a film, rented from one of the new video libraries which had sprung up.

Michael Fay lived with his family in a house on Brae Grove, Ballygowan, a pleasant street of terraced houses many miles from the paramilitary hotspots of North and West Belfast. His widow had believed he was going to visit their 14-month-old daughter, who was sick in hospital. Instead, on his way there, he was abducted by two armed men who drove him in his car to a garage. One of the armed men was Billy Giles. The garage, in the Tullcarnet area, was rented by Giles and was to be the venue for the sectarian murder of Michael Fay. Giles shot Michael through the head twice, and then, with his accomplice William Wright, placed the dead body into the boot of his car, and left it on Mountregan Avenue, Dundonald. Last seen alive at 15:30 on a Friday, it was one hour short of a full day before the RUC, accompanied by Michael Fay's brother, opened the abandoned car and discovered the murdered man.

The statement released by the organisation responsible for murdering Michael may have claimed it was directly linked to a desire to avenge Lennie Murphy, but it was a very different murder that radicalised Billy Giles, in his own words "turning him into a killer." That murder, of a 20-year-old Sunday School teacher named Karen McKeown, is one of a number that this article will reexamine, identifying a trail of violent actions that claimed innocent lives and ultimately concluded with a suicide, 25 years later.

“Take on a Strandman, and you take on the Strand” – The Catholic Defence League.

In December 1977, Magill published an excellent article written by Kevin Myers about the Short Strand. Among many fascinating observations on the area, he had this to say:

The letters CDL mean little to most people in Belfast. They evoke small response from Strand people when you mention them, but that is not from ignorance. Probably the best equipped and most secret organisation in the Short Strand is the CDL The Catholic Defence League - which does not lose guns or personnel, and waits for the day of the great conflagration. That that conflagration seems to be receding does not seem to lower the CDL's guard. They encourage silence about their existence, but they are there, awaiting the fateful day. While some Strand residents' dream of freedom from the centre to the sea, others remember where they live, in a tiny enclave surrounded by a vast Protestant population.

On the 8th of November, 1979, loyalist gunmen shot dead two Short Strand men, Marius O'Neill and Paul McCrory, both aged 23. In his Magill article, Myers had written that "if you take on a Strandman, be prepared to take on the Strand." Within two hours of the O'Neill and McCrory murders, two members of the CDL had taken weapons from an arms dump, scaled a wall of the Sirocco works nearby, opened up a security guard's hut and shot dead the Protestant civilian Edward McMaster. The CDL members later convicted of involvement in the attack (Noel Halfpenny and James Burns), in keeping with an agreement between the CDL and the IRA, served their jail terms on IRA wings.

Shortly after the Magill article was published, Kevin Myers received a phone call from an IRA member who told him the IRA wanted to talk to him and that he should attend a pub in the Clonard area at a specified time and date. This Myers did, went into a back room and was confronted by a then IRA Belfast Brigade staff member, who later became an elected Sinn Fein representative and a household name. Let's call him P. O'Neill. He informed Myers that his article had damaged "the cause" and demanded to know his source. Myers informed P. O'Neill that "your cause is not my cause" and that, of course, he wouldn't reveal his source. The meeting went on for some time, with Myers describing it as the closest thing to a court martial that he had experienced.

Murder Begets Murder: The Logic of Sectarian Gunmen

On the 24th of September 1982, 28-year-old Stephen Andrew Crowe spent the day drinking in various bars in Sandy Row. Later, he was given a Smith & Wesson revolver supposedly to "store." Instead, Crowe "found himself" in the Short Strand, where he burst into a house at random and shot at a 21-year-old male inhabitant. The man was hit three times, but Crowe missed the man's girlfriend who was sitting with him. The man survived. Crowe later went to the Markets area where he opened fire at a group of people, missing all of them. He was sentenced to 15 years at his trial in 1983, where he was described as an alcoholic who had been drinking since the age of 12. Crowe had previously been charged with armed robbery – using a revolver, and other theft charges.

Crowe was arrested hours after the shootings, remanded, and later tried and convicted. But it appears that for some men with access to guns, the arrest was not enough. The "reprisal" shootings carried out were among the most wanton and vicious of the entire conflict, made even worse by the fact that no convictions followed.

A man, or men, armed with INLA weapons, previously used to attempt to murder a DUP man, Billy Dickinson, just over three weeks earlier, shot dead 68-year-old civilian Billy Nixon and shot and fatally wounded 20-year-old Karen McKeown. The murder of Ms McKeown was particularly squalid and brutal. She walked out of the church where she had been attending a service, was approached from behind and shot in the neck, the gun a matter of inches from her. She survived for three weeks before succumbing to her injuries. As far as I am aware, nobody has ever been arrested for these murders. In all of the killings and events that I have looked into, the absence of information has never been greater. The INLA, for their part, denied any part in the double murder, and said that they did not target people because of their religion but individuals who were behind such sectarian attacks and actively promoted them" were targets (Belfast Telegraph, 01/10/82).

So who killed Karen McKeown and Billy Nixon? An obvious answer is the INLA. After all the weapons were INLA, and they had a unit operating in East Belfast in 1982 who in addition to the attempt on Billy Dickinson, had shot dead the former highly influential loyalist leader, John McKeague.

But could it have been the CDL using INLA guns? Or CDL members who had an affiliation with the INLA? Murdering a female barely out of her teens was unusual, but not entirely unique, to republican paramilitaries. 17-year-old Heather Thompson was shot dead in the mid-1970s. But the IRA hadn't carried out an overtly sectarian murder for some time, and the INLA were still a year away from Darkley. Could it have been a case of men and women from the Strand being attacked, and therefore CDL members attacked men and women from the Protestant community?

One challenge to my theorising that the CDL was involved comes from the then INLA member Gerard Steenson, who was imprisoned on the words of a supergrass. A "comm" he sent to comrades on the outside had this to say about the murderers of Ms McKeown and Mr Nixon:

Do the current INLA L/S (leadership) have the potential to further the movements' aims? No. Even worse, they permit Darkley and murder old men, and Sunday school teachers.

Steenson’s comms from inside prison are highly articulate, the work of man who appears to abhor sectarian murders, and contrary to “Doctor Death” persona in the media, he was a man capable of sober political reflection.

The Aftermath: From Revenge to Ruin

In 1997, the BBC broadcast three seminal series on the Troubles, Provos, Loyalists, and Brits. Groundbreaking at the time, the presenter Peter Taylor interviewed those who had "stained Northern Ireland with blood" with shocking results. An especially memorable interview was with UVF member Billy Giles. As previously discussed, Giles had committed a sectarian murder in 1982, for which he was convicted and served a life sentence. The murder of Michael Fay was condemned in strong terms across the political spectrum, and his funeral was an ecumenical affair, with more than 40 Protestant clergy attending the Catholic service. Amidst the commendable demonstration of faith and unity at the funeral, however, was the haunting sight of the now widowed Mary Fay sobbing "I don't want him to go away."

Again, as we have seen, an organisation calling itself the Protestant Action Force put out a statement claiming they were responsible for killing Michael Fay. But what drove Giles to kill was the murder of Karen McKeown, as he admitted himself in Taylor's documentary. He also said this, about becoming a murderer:

When it happened, it felt to me that, that somebody had reached down inside me and ripped, ripped my insides out. That's what it felt like. It felt as if somebody had just put their hand down in through my head and just ripped the inside out of me, and I was empty - I felt empty.

You hear a bang and it's too late. You hear the bang and that's it. It's too late then, you've went, you've went somewhere you've never been before and it's not a very nice place and you can't, you can't stop it, it's too late then … (1) never felt a whole person again. Never felt, never felt like that again. So I lost something that day I don't think I'll ever get back.

A year after that interview, Billy Giles took his own life. A chain of events that started in 1982 with a drunk, Stephen Crowe, shooting at civilians, ended with deaths, bereaved families, heartbroken partners, and decades in jail.

⏩ Brandon Sullivan is a middle-aged West Belfast émigré. He juggles fatherhood & marriage with working in a policy environment and writing for TPQ about the conflict, films, books, and politics.

Sectarian Murder In 1982 🪶 When Revenge Ruled Belfast

Brandon Sullivan ✍ I wasn't particularly interested in seeing this film at the cinema, Baby Girl, directed by Halina Reijn.


And having now watched it twice, I'm still unsure if I think it's a good film. But it certainly is a cultural object worthy of discussion, and that alone perhaps attests to a certain quality it possesses.

Central to this film is Nicole Kidman's character, Romy. The high-powered, wealthy CEO of a "robotic automation company," Romy presents as highly capable, yet clearly discontent. Through a fairly contrived scenario, she is introduced to Samuel, a 20-something, chiselled man who is employed as an intern at her company. Samuel is played by Harris Dickinson, who gives an extremely impressive performance. Nicole Kidman, at 57, is basically double Dickinson's age. The age dynamic is present throughout. Immediately, Samuel identifies something in Romy, what the source of her unhappiness might be and, crucially, how he could be the person to give her what she isn't quite sure she needs. Her unhappiness, he seems to instinctively understand, is a type of sexual frustration that has lasted for decades and is centred around having never acted on a strong desire to be sexually submissive. Samuel, for reasons never really explained, is a man comfortable with fulfilling her desires, which are presumably in line with his own.

The film succeeds or fails on the dynamic between Samuel and Romy, and I found it compelling. Who was exploiting whom? Or was nobody being exploited? Except, perhaps, Romy's husband (Jacob), and Samuel's girlfriend, another senior colleague. Romy's relationship with her husband, excellently portrayed by Antonio Banderas, provides a grating realism affecting Romy from fully enjoying the intense sexual ecstasy as she gradually, and then completely, enters into a fully sexually submissive role with Samuel.

I found the film most interesting when it contrasted those with a deep interest in BDSM with those who didn't. Romy variously told her husband that she wasn't like other women, that she "wasn't normal" and that she'd had "dark" and "depraved" fantasies as far back as she could remember. Clearly contemptuous of what he perceived as the selfishness of her acting on these impulses, Jacob spits at her that she jeopardised "what was most important … (their children) for banal sexual fantasies." Romy never revels in her fantasies, and even when in the midst of the highly charged sexual affair she has with Samuel, her visible torment never really seems to lift.

Samuel, unsurprisingly, is not a one-woman man, and Romy is clearly threatened by his dating his senior colleague, Esme (played by Sophie Smith). At a club night, Samuel texts Romy, who lies to Jacob about where she's going (and disappoints her daughter). When she gets there, she sees Samuel dancing, clearly on drugs, and euphoric. He gives something to Romy to smoke, and she does. She then asks Samuel, "do you do with her what you do with me?" - to which he replies "no, she's not like you. I'm not like this when I'm with her. That's why I like you. And why I like her." This is as close as we get to understanding Samuel. Romy repeatedly said, in the early days of their entanglement that she was "worried" about him, or felt "protective" – Samuel retorted that she "keeps saying that – I'm OK" and that she should be worried, because he could make one phone call to the company’s hierarchy and reveal all and she'd be finished. Later on, Samuel asks Romy if she wants to lose everything and is using him to do this, a sort of "suicide by cop" scenario. This shows that Samuel has at least some awareness of the conflict raging in Romy's inner world.

But Samuel's inner world is never really fully explored. Why does he do what he does? What drives him? He doesn't seem depressed, but he doesn't seem particularly happy either. Many men would envy the charisma he possesses and his ability to seduce women from a range of backgrounds, but he seems to pay some sort of psychic price for his actions. Or perhaps he's just a sensualist, and the sex, drugs, and NYC EDM are him living his best life. But I didn't think that's the whole story. He wasn't like the tortured lead character in Steve McQueen's film Shame, living a life in the throes of sex addiction, but neither was he a sexually liberated hedonist. So what was going on? It is a testament to Dickonson's skill as an actor that we are left curious about this complex, confident, yet quiet character. Perhaps Samuel would in time develop the crushing addiction issues featured in Shame, but I don't think they're cut from the same cloth.

Apparently, Reijn was inspired by films such as Basic Instinct and 9&1/2 Weeks, but I think Baby Girl would make a good companion piece with Shame. Samuel and Michael Fassbender's character in Shame are both men for whom seducing women is easy but who have difficulties maintaining loving relationships (Samuel to a lesser extent). And Romy is not as troubled as the character Sissy in Shame. But neither is she untroubled. In fact, her alienation from her outwardly successful life has shades of Shame to it. For me, what was missing was the inner world of Samuel. Dickinson said that he devised a backstory for Samuel, and that part of his inhabiting the character was imagining that Samuel was "wading around in his mess." This is interesting and hints at what I believe was missing from the film.

Samuel and Romy are both participants in a game, and both believe in what they are doing. To the extent that Samuel challenges someone who bluntly states that BDSM means nothing with a simple "sorry, but you are wrong." For Romy, clearly, it is almost a form of therapy. Is it the same for Samuel? 

Whilst almost everyone is possessed of a sexual drive, not everyone risks the fabric of their lives to act out in a transgressive way. In this film, it is the female lead who does this and takes serious risks. It's a much less hazardous scenario for Samuel, who simply doesn't have the stakes that Romy does. But would he be so driven to engage if the consequences for participation were potentially so serious? I don't think so.

Baby Girl is a conversation starter. Should we actualise that which we crave? Or should we be careful what we wish for?

It's worth a watch. And it's given me a few appreciation for a George Michael song, and some modern EDM.
 
⏩ Brandon Sullivan is a middle-aged West Belfast émigré. He juggles fatherhood & marriage with working in a policy environment and writing for TPQ about the conflict, films, books, and politics.

Baby Girl

Brandon Sullivan 🔖 with a review of the latest work from Martin Dillon.


Introduction

In preparation for writing this review, I thought back to 2003 when I read Martin Dillon’s previous book The Trigger Men. Back then, I seriously rated Dillon as an investigative journalist and an author. I had first read The Shankill Butchers when I was in my late teens, and it provoked a strength and depth of feelings about the conflict that simply weren’t there beforehand. The historian and writer Gareth Mulvenna wrote that after he read The Shankill Butchers book it felt like someone poured “toxic glue” in his brains. That accurately summaries how I felt. The book retains the capacity to shock, disturb, and infuriate.

But one thing it did to me was inspire me to seek out all of Dillon’s books, which I did, one by one. With the exception of his biography on Blair Mayne, I have read all of Martin Dillon’s non-fiction books, and one of his novels, The Serpent’s Tail. The novel was good, I have to say, one of the better ‘Troubles” novels that I have read. Although, I read it some time ago and may think differently now. Yes, Quillers, at one point in time, I would have emphatically agreed with the late Dr. Conor Cruise O'Brien, who described Martin Dillon as "our Virgil to that Inferno.”

Dillon’s book on the Butchers was the first that I read about loyalism. The Dirty War (1990) also shocked me – in my late teens and early 20s, I was still really quite naïve about the nature of state violence. My first doubt about Dillon’s take on historical matters came about when I was reading 25 Years of Terror: The IRA's War Against the British (1996). Dillon wrote that at the time of the 1994 ceasefire, the IRA had never been so dangerous. This just didn’t ring true to me, and I wondered why an author of Dillon’s pedigree had written such a thing. But, I didn’t dwell on it, and in 2003 bought a copy of The Trigger Men, a hardback copy, such was my eagerness to get it. I was disappointed that the chapters on Lenny Murphy and Michael Stone were basically lifted from his previous books. And I questioned his assertion that Johnny Adair was “Officer Commanding” the UFF across Northern Ireland. It appeared that Dillon had bought into the hype that Adair created for himself. Dillon’s work had to a significant degree inspired me to seek out more historical inquiry about the Troubles. But at a certain point, his books no longer informed me, and increasingly led to frustration and irritation. I had, basically, moved on.

Other than Crossing the Line, his patchy but at times fascinating memoir in 2017, this is Dillon’s first book in more than 20 years. Quite an event. As part of the PR Blitz, Dillon appeared on a number of podcasts. On one, The Good Listener which is hosted by the affable Irish man John Hadden, Dillon got combative when asked about an actor’s portrayal of the late IRA Belfast Brigade commander, Brendan Hughes, and on some other occasions. Hadden did well to temper Dillon’s bolshiness. My own research and writing has put me in touch with a range of people well-informed about book releases and promotional activities, and so it was that I actually knew of an interview Dillon did with the wife of a former prominent paramilitary. The interview participant withdrew her consent for Dillon to use the interview. In my opinion, in one podcast, Dillon gave enough information about this woman’s husband to identify her. I thought it was quite a shoddy thing to have done. I also have it on good authority, as they say, that Dillon backed out of a podcast which would have involved a well-regarded author and expert on loyalism who just happened to have published respectful and constructive criticism, alongside a high degree of praise, of Dillon’s work interviewing him.

So, these were the circumstances leading up to me receiving a copy of the book for review. For full disclosure, I have tried to contact Martin Dillon, inviting him to comment on the reappraisal of his Shankill Butchers book which I have been co-authoring. Thus far, I haven’t heard anything back. I would be nothing but respectful if he were to get in touch.

Other books about women in the Troubles

Dillon accurately identified a gap in the market in writing a book centred on women’s voices. But this is not the first. 40 years ago, a remarkable book titled Only the rivers run free : Northern Ireland, the women's war was published, written by Eileen Fairweather. I highly recommend this as a document of a time and a place. It is not, however, free from error. I am dubious about some of the book’s claims about the identify of “Captain Black”, for example. There is also Sisters in Cells by Áine and Eibhlín Níc Giolla. And, of course, much work exists on the Price sisters.

The Book

The book is a collection of chapters each centred around a woman who had some significance in the conflict. There are strong stories, and Dillon is clearly a skilled interviewer. I was eager to read the chapter featuring Tracy Coulter, the ex-partner of the UDA killer Stevie McKeag. I was not surprised to learn that McKeag was extremely violent and controlling towards his female partners, but was surprised to learn that at UDA meetings the young McKeag would openly threaten the life of his partner’s father, Jackie Coulter, himself a senior UDA man. I think this would be the equivalent of a member of an IRA ASU threatening a member of Northern Command at an IRA meeting. That was an extraordinary insight into the UDA. But I felt that the compromised the chapter by using a recollection from Tracy about a ruckus in her family home when she was a child. A drunk Catholic man had gotten lost and broke into the Coulter family home where Jackie Coulter chased him. The book reports that Jackie walked the man to the Springfield Road, where he lived. This brought to mind a recollection from a son of Tucker Lyttle, who walked in on his father and some other men beating an unfortunate man they had tied to a chair. I have trouble believing the account Tracy gave, though that may well be her recollection, but I wonder if Dillon questioned it. I find it difficult to believe that a Catholic man would break into a UDA brigadier’s house or, if he did, that he would survive it.

The book is weak on factual details as it contains some blatant errors, but strong on personal reflections. For example, he mentions the IRA’s Northern Command existed in the early 1970s, when it had not in fact the IRA did not create it till much later. But then again, the reflections of the widow of a soldier killed by the IRA were poignant and important. Many hundreds of families on mainland Britain suffered bereavement because of the conflict, and we have not heard their voices very much.

An academic shared with me inaccuracies he uncovered on the chapter about the IRA member Martina Anderson. He asked me not to name him. I have not given the full list:

She was arrested the first time in 1980 and hid in Donegal and then got arrested in 1985. Here is what Dillon wrote:

After she fled Derry, she vanished from the Special Branch radar and was not seen again until she was apprehended fourteen years later, on 24 June 1985, in a flat in Glasgow.

If she had been missing for 14 years, she would've been 9 when she went to Donegal!

He then writes:

Martina Anderson was a seasoned operative, having been in Britain for years according to Scotland Yard’s counterterrorism experts. (184)

How could she have been in Scotland for years if she was hiding in Donegal as he claims McGuinness told her to go into hiding in Donegal!? (179)

And so it goes. This isn’t a bad book, but it is a frustrating one. Dillon’s pedigree is such many will consider his work the final word. I was certainly someone who was in that school of thought, and it is therefore a pity that inaccuracies sit alongside fascinating stories and personal insights. Worth a read, but buy it second-hand.

Conclusion

Alongside the praise from Dr Conor Cruise O’Brien which I quoted at the beginning of this review is a vignette from The Irish Times which hailed Martin Dillon as "one of the most creative writers of our time.” I think that this compliment may prove to be unintentionally accurate and we should no longer consider it praise for an investigative journalist and historian.

Martin Dillon, 2025. The Sorrow and the Loss: The Tragic Shadow Cast by the Troubles on the Lives of Women. Merrion Press. ISBN-13: ‎978-1785375415.

⏩Brandon Sullivan is a middle-aged West Belfast émigré. He juggles fatherhood & marriage with working in a policy environment and writing for TPQ about the conflict, films, books, and politics.

The Sorrow & the Loss

Brandon Sullivan 🔖In preparation for this, I looked at my reviews of Christopher Owen’s already published works: a collection of poems, A Vortex of Securocrats and a novella, Dethrone God.


The author’s most recent book, a novel named Soineanta Maskirovka, in common with his previous works demands the reader’s thoughtful attention from the beginning. What does the title mean? I’ll leave it for you to decide, as part of the pleasure literature like this brings is in the deciphering. The cover art is reminiscent of a certain type of Troubles era poster. The artwork may have played a part in my interpretation of some of this work, but so, too, did knowledge of Owens’ previous publications, and of course, there is my own areas of research and interest.

The central character in this story is Gilbert Hood. The book is set contemporaneously, but is concerned with Gilbert delving into his own, and others', pasts. Gilbert in some ways reminded me of Stasi Captain Gerd Wiesler from the excellent 2006 German film The Lives of Others. Outwardly, he is not a colourful personality: he is someone who avoids noise and people, and his former colleagues appear to find him borderline condescending. Indeed, like the Stasi officer Wiesler, Gilbert appears to exist as something approaching an automaton. However, Gilbert has a rich inner world which can appear overwhelmed by the present and, in part, manifests itself via a YouTube channel in which he reviews films. This element of Gilbert’s character, in some ways, reminded me of the Ian Smith character, in Irvine Welsh’s book The Acid House (the chapter titled Snuff), although Gilbert does not share that individual’s lethal nihilism.

The film reviews are one of a number of plot devices which allow the reader to view society via Gilbert. These devices add value to the story, their subtlety is such that it was only with re-reading that I noticed their positioning and decided to pay more attention to them. Like Owens' previous published works, Soineanta Maskirovka demands the reader to return, and its brevity allows for this. So it is that this novel opens with a officious and earnest reproduced letter informing Gilbert of how much he will receive for his voluntary redundancy. Then, we are invited to “listen” (via a transcript of his YouTube film review channel) to Gilbert’s thoughts on the 1919 film The Chink and the Child which continues into, what I took to be, a subtle comment on wokeism. I have always found devices like this tantalising and enjoyable. The files John Strang kept in Irvine Welsh’s The Acid House, for example, or the police files on Frank Costello in Scorsese’s brilliant film The Departed. Soineanta Maskirovka treats us to a few of these joys. The film review also discusses the East End of London, which will feature later in the book.

The job, which Gilbert is made redundant from, changed radically, and not to his liking. He has concerns, and with good reason. He seeks to travel, researching the past to look at his antecedents and to other locations for the same reason. What he finds poses questions, which might resonate with those from the six counties. This isn’t in any way a story of the Troubles, but I found there were suggestions of it in the prose. I don’t think this was intentional, but I found it interesting, and wonder if it’s possible for Belfast to feature in creative writing without the conflict casting a shadow.

One of the strengths of this book is how invested the reader feels in the character. I didn’t think Gilbert was the type of person I’d have warmed to, but I wanted to see how the various threads of his life were tied up. I felt a range of conflicted emotions for him, and towards the people and institutions that arguably failed him. Gilbert was a man with a story, and that story was told in atmospheric settings.

I think that this novel shows a maturation of Christopher Owens as a writer. Whilst saying that, I preferred Dethrone Gods. But it’s a matter of taste. I think Owens will continue to produce work of merit and interest. I’d love to read a serious Troubles novel written by him, but I think his interest may lie elsewhere.

Either way, this is a good, solid piece of work and bodes well for the future.

Christopher Owens, 2025. Soineanta Maskirovka. Publisher:‎ Down by Law Books. ASIN: ‎B0DWLTQL2R.

⏩Brandon Sullivan is a middle-aged West Belfast émigré. He juggles fatherhood & marriage with working in a policy environment and writing for TPQ about the conflict, films, books, and politics.

Soineanta Maskirovka

Brandon Sullivan ✍  delves into claims by the loyalist activist, Billy Hutchinson. 

Introduction

Fifty years ago this week, Billy Hutchinson and his accomplice, Tom Winstone, drove a short distance from the Shankill Road onto the Falls Road and shot dead two men, half-brothers Michael Gerard Loughran (18), and Eric Edward Morgan (27). I’ve chosen to quote in full what a cousin of the murdered men wrote some years ago when the murders came to prominence in the media, this time because of what Hutchinson said about them:

Billy. It was murdering Catholics. For being Catholics.
The morning you turned your car round to drive down the Falls and kill them is as clear now for me as it was 40 years ago.
My cousins were labourers, as was their father. They wanted to get a black taxi down the Falls but there was only room for one. The father got in and they walked. You killed them because they were there. You’d have shot their father, a Protestant, as well if he had been with them.
I had just turned 12 and was sitting in a huge new school when I was taken out of class to see my father, waiting in the school office. I spent the next two days watching thousands of people, young and old, come through the open door of my granny’s tiny living room in a terrace house off the Springfield Road where my cousin Eric had lived. A few albums on a shelf (Tubular Bells at the front), a pile of Military Modelling magazines, a box of paints and miniscule brushes for painting tiny pewter Napoleonic figures for war games – and that was it; all he left.
And the sobbing, the uncontrollable sobbing, of my father bent over his coffin in front of thousands in a packed St Paul’s on the morning of the burial, that brought embarrassment to a selfish 12-year-old boy.
I have the bus token and the few coins he had in his pocket from that morning.
I have the pewter figures, painted by a solitary man who wanted to escape from the world around him.
I’ve been back to Cupar Street and Bombay Street to see their names on the memorial. They aren’t in the republican section, Billy. There were no death notices, flags or paramilitary displays – then or since – because there was no reason to have them there. (highlights mine)
The “intelligence” you speak of; was it simply one or both of them looked familiar? Maybe you had burnt them out of their house a few years before? Was it the same intelligence that everyone who was a taig was a Provie? The same “intelligence” that Gusty Spence, a relative of my father, had used in 1966 to do just what you did that clear, sharp October morning?​
The idea that any taig will do, Billy? ​Well it won’t.
The IRA didn’t kill them, Billy. You did. And it is you who has to live with that.


I found this to be a far, far more eloquent and damning criticism of sectarian murder than anything I have managed to write, or indeed anyone else, and in its simplicity and honesty, leaves little room for anything beyond cliched and offensive rebuttals. I salute the man who wrote this.

Billy Hutchinson’s Rationale for the Murders he Committed

26 years ago, Billy Hutchinson swallowed slowly when Peter Taylor asked him about the double murder he was convicted of. The interview was taking place on the seminal “Loyalists” BBC series. Hutchinson looked uncomfortable, and muttered something about it “being 25 years ago” adding that he had “no regrets” and that he had been “part of a war, and that war had to be fought.”

In an Irish Times interview in 2020, he had this to say:

The “strategy” from loyalist paramilitaries was “that if they killed enough Catholics then the Catholic community would in turn put pressure on the IRA to disband,” writes Hutchinson. “This was pure sectarianism, and it didn’t work ... at the time, however, I truly believed that if we pushed the Catholic community to the edge, they would go begging the IRA to stop their terror campaign.

That seems to me that Billy endorsed the loyalist campaign of murdering Catholics, for being Catholics, exactly as the cousin of Michael Loughran and Edward Morgan said.

However, in his autobiography, written with Gareth Mulvenna, he gave this account:

Loughran and Morgan had been identified as active republicans by the YCV (Young Citizen Volunteers). How accurate the information was, I don’t know. At 7:30 a.m. our active service unit had spotted them on the Falls Road and assassinated the two men as they passed the junction of Northumberland Street, just yards from the Shankill.

In 2014, he said this:

Asked if he regretted killing the two Catholics, Mr Hutchinson told the News Letter : "What I'm saying is that I regret every murder, but let's be clear that it's very easy for you to say that, but what I will say to you is that I didn't do anything without intelligence."

He said his view was he “was fighting a war” and that the “IRA left me with no option”.

Hutchinson claims to have “evidence” demonstrating that the two men he murdered were “active republicans.”

Hutchinson appeared on the Good Listener podcast, and in a wide-ranging interview had this to say about the double murder:

I can tell you now, there was evidence against them and that’s the issue, but because I know what I don’t want to do is annoy people who are victims. So for that very reason, it’s very simple, it’s been in the papers, it’s been repeated a hundred times, so like there’s nothing more than I can tell you that hasn’t been in the papers but you know, from our point of view, our intelligence was good and it was proven, it just wasn’t anything else. But, you know, all you’ve got to do is look at the death notices and see who had it in.

The interviewer asked “meaning … mean what?”

Hutchinson went on:

Meaning the IRA Cumanns (Irish for Unit or Branch) had them in … you don’t put that in for people who aren’t in a Cumann.

This interested me. I had previously searched the British and Irish newspaper archives, and could find no death notices. I then went into the Linenhall Library and asked to see microfilm of the Irish News from October 1974. There were indeed a number of death notices for Michael Loughran and Edward Morgan, 35 in total. Mostly from parents, uncles, grandparents, and a particularly poignant one from a girlfriend of one of the men. There were also notices from a residents association, neighbours, and the “shopkeepers and residents” of Springfield Road.

There was not a single notice from a “cumann”. However, two that were of immediate interest were from “John Wilson, Magilligan” and “Finbarr McKenna, A Wing, Crumlin Road Jail.”

Finbarr McKenna, like the murdered men, was a Clonard man. A mural commemorates him and his death attempting to bomb Springfield Road barracks in 1987. John Wilson, I couldn’t find much information on, but I don’t think he was anything beyond an IRA auxiliary.

The relevance of two IRA men leaving death notices.

Hutchinson, in his memoir, tells this story about a friend of his who was not involved in any paramilitary organisation:

On the way home to the Mountainview area between the Woodvale and Crumlin roads, one of the guys who I was very friendly with … stopped off at a chippy in Ardoyne. As soon as he walked back out onto the Crumlin Road with his bag of chips, he was bundled into a car and taken to a house in the republican part of Ardoyne, where he was tortured for several hours. During a break in his interrogation, he managed to throw himself out of a window and make a bid for freedom. Luckily, some sympathetic locals discovered him, and he was rushed off to hospital, where he was eventually able to make a full recovery and speak to the police after a period of three weeks. The police asked him what he had been questioned about. ‘Hutchie. From Mackies. They wanted to know everything about him.’ After they had finished telling me this, the police advised me to leave Mackies immediately and to never come back. My mate’s dad offered to drive me back to Matchett Street, but the army said he needn’t bother, that they would leave me home. Always keen to make me feel uneasy, the soldiers drove me down Cupar Street, where they left me off on the Falls Road end.

The men Hutchinson murdered had a family home on Cupar Street. If Loughran and Morgan were indeed IRA members, would they have ventured to within yards of the Shankill Road, where Hutchinson says he observed them and murdered them?

And if the IRA had murdered the man mentioned in the quoted paragraph above, and Hutchinson left a death notice, would that have been justification for the killing? If having two death notices from paramilitaries was evidence of being a paramilitary, virtually every single man in Hutchinson’s Shankill Road community would be “legitimate targets” according to his own rationale.

The fact is that, at that time, many young men from close-knit communities were ending up in prison for paramilitary activities. They had networks of friends and relatives outside their organisations. That is natural and to be expected.

The Irish News Archive contains the Andersonstown News from 1972. There is not a single notice for Loughran or Morgan in it, though their murder is discussed. There is an article about Finbarr McKenna, from September 1974, alleging torture and abuse he and his family endured at the hands of the British army in September 1974, a few weeks before he had a notice placed for his friends.

I am left considering what the cousin of Loughran and Morgan said about there being “no death notices” – Hutchinson must surely have read what that man said about his actions, and still he said on a popular podcast that there were indeed death notices that proved his victims were “active republicans.”

I have not been able to find a single shred of evidence that either of the murdered men were anything other than labourers, with a Protestant father, who had the misfortune of either encountering Hutchinson on that day randomly, or someone, somewhere, claiming they were something that they were not.

I wonder if Billy Hutchinson would do his victim’s families the courtesy of saying where these damning death notices actually are?

⏩Brandon Sullivan is a middle-aged West Belfast émigré. He juggles fatherhood & marriage with working in a policy environment and writing for TPQ about the conflict, films, books, and politics.

The Murders Billy Hutchinson Was Convicted Of 🪶 “Legitimate Targets?”